Monday, 14 August 2023 06:06

Use by the Public Sector of Private Sector Personal Data

Written by  Teresa Scassa
Rate this item
(0 votes)

The following is a short excerpt from a new paper which looks at the public sector use of private sector personal data (Teresa Scassa, “Public Sector Use of Private Sector Personal Data: Towards Best Practices”, forthcoming in (2024) 47:2 Dalhousie Law Journal ) The full pre-print version of the paper is available here: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4538632

Governments seeking to make data-driven decisions require the data to do so. Although they may already hold large stores of administrative data, their ability to collect new or different data is limited both by law and by practicality. In our networked, Internet of Things society, the private sector has become a source of abundant data about almost anything – but particularly about people and their activities. Private sector companies collect a wide variety of personal data, often in high volumes, rich in detail, and continuously over time. Location and mobility data, for example, are collected by many different actors, from cellular service providers to app developers. Financial sector organizations amass rich data about the spending and borrowing habits of consumers. Even genetic data is collected by private sector companies. The range of available data is constantly broadening as more and more is harvested, and as companies seek secondary markets for the data they collect.

Public sector use of private sector data is fraught with important legal and public policy considerations. Chief among these is privacy since access to such data raises concerns about undue government intrusion into private lives and habits. Data protection issues implicate both public and private sector actors in this context, and include notice and consent, as well as data security. And, where private sector data is used to shape government policies and actions, important questions about ethics, data quality, the potential for discrimination, and broader human rights questions also arise. Alongside these issues are interwoven concerns about transparency, as well as necessity and proportionality when it comes to the conscription by the public sector of data collected by private companies.

This paper explores issues raised by public sector access to and use of personal data held by the private sector. It considers how such data sharing is legally enabled and within what parameters. Given that laws governing data sharing may not always keep pace with data needs and public concerns, this paper also takes a normative approach which examines whether and in what circumstances such data sharing should take place. To provide a factual context for discussion of the issues, the analysis in this paper is framed around two recent examples from Canada that involved actual or attempted access by government agencies to private sector personal data for public purposes. The cases chosen are different in nature and scope. The first is the attempted acquisition and use by Canada’s national statistics organization, Statistics Canada (StatCan), of data held by credit monitoring companies and financial institutions to generate economic statistics. The second is the use, during the COVID-19 pandemic, of mobility data by the Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) to assess the effectiveness of public health policies in reducing the transmission of COVID-19 during lockdowns. The StatCan example involves the compelled sharing of personal data by private sector actors; while the PHAC example involves a government agency that contracted for the use of anonymized data and analytics supplied by private sector companies. Each of these instances generated significant public outcry. This negative publicity no doubt exceeded what either agency anticipated. Both believed that they had a legal basis to gather and/or use the data or analytics, and both believed that their actions served the public good. Yet the outcry is indicative of underlying concerns that had not properly been addressed.

Using these two quite different cases as illustrations, the paper examines the issues raised by the use of private sector data by government. Recognizing that such practices are likely to multiply, it also makes recommendations for best practices. Although the examples considered are Canadian and are shaped by the Canadian legal context, most of the issues they raise are of broader relevance. Part I of this paper sets out the two case studies that are used to tease out and illustrate the issues raised by public sector use of private sector data. Part II discusses the different issues and makes recommendations.

The full pre-print version of the paper is available here: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4538632

Teresa Scassa

Latest from Teresa Scassa

Related items (by tag)

back to top